PlayStation 3 » Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots Box Cover ← →

7,472   10 ^(?)  

ok, i think you just obliterated every MGS4 box, nay, every SINGLE box on this site.
one of the few that can rightfully earn a 5/5
BRAVO!

[ Reply ]

oh wait, emerges is misspelled. 2/5
=P
sorry for the double post

[ Reply ]

Looks you put alot of effort into this man! I can see this as the official box 5/5!!!!

[ Reply ]

Yeah, just fix up "Emerges" and its absolutely perfect.
Since that little flaw doesnt take away more than 1 billionth of a point, and since there are no other flaws, I have no choice but to give you a 5/5.

[ Reply ]

You forgot the spine.

[ Reply ]

I'm giving it 5/5 because its awesome, that's probably what the official box will look like.

[ Reply ]

Damn...thats....amazing!!!!
5/5 :)

[ Reply ]

Awesome job , there are no flaws .


5/5

[ Reply ]

I like it though i think the images are a bit too dark.

[ Reply ]

...you still forgot the spine.

But I didn't say anything about the box in my first post, sorry. It is a damned good piece of work. But, like I've been saying, you forgot the spine, which is a crucial piece. It - quite literally - connects the front and back, and it's what distinguishes the box when stacked up in a pile.

4.5/5

[ Reply ]

#13, it really isn't that crucial... most spines are pretty plain, and don't really contribute to the box art in any way.
and since (if you haven't already noticed) these boxes aren't real, i doubt anyone has to worry about stacking them up ^_^

[ Reply ]

The spine is the Center of Balance, or something, people such as I normally like, in this case it does'nt matter at all, heck I'll go to say its better without it.How cool is too pices of the case slanted side-to-side? The best of both worlds aswell, losing none of the high image res by 3Derizing and so shifting the image, yet still having the the 3D frame to give the allusion of a box container so yeah this box is awesome.

[ Reply ]

5/5 awesomely excellent

[ Reply ]

It's still the matter of the fact.

I understand where you're coming from, and I'm not trying to hassle you about it, but as you said, these aren't real. But if you don't submit a box as satire, we take the artist's intent with their boxart as trying to as real as possible.

If you've seen other boxarts - such as the MK Armagedon box that's in the top 10 - they use the spine to connect the artwork.

It seems like I'm hounding you about the spine, and I'm sorry. I don't mean to sound like an ass, but it's still damned impressive.

4.5/5

[ Reply ]

#18, ItÂ’s not the matter of fact; donÂ’t throw your thoughts around as fact.

The matter of fact is this site is not called ‘‘realistic box arts’’

This site is for a category of fan art, box artists can go for realism if they want and try to predict how the makers would do it or could make their own take on a box art, aslong as it has artwork, logos and something that can be used in a real box, its classifies as a ‘box art’, it can be the artist’s take on things; art is in the title of the site, realism isn’t, realism doesn’t always matter.

[ Reply ]

o_o awesome boxart man, i really love it <3
just some shinkawa art on the front now and it's perfect like a real MGS cover XD

[ Reply ]

Good...No!Excellent! 5/5

[ Reply ]

Very nice 5/5 infact blows most of em away!

[ Reply ]

#18 Fanmade Boxarts are not ment to real as possible , It like most fanmade boxarts can real as the offical one .

You haven't even made boxart .

[ Reply ]

WTF!!! You gave this a fuckin 1/5? This is awsome. I hope whoever did give it a 1/5 feels good about themselves, cause that wasn't nescecary.

Great Job man, 5/5

[ Reply ]

yeah i forget to rate this ...... nice job man 5/5 well earned

[ Reply ]

#26, when i said yeah i didn't mean that i rated this 1/5 ... just to clear your heads

[ Reply ]

Where is the backround you used on the front?! I can't find it anywere!!! I want to use it for siggy.

[ Reply ]

#1, oh, I thought you said this was your second box! I'd be like what the fuck?!!? Awsome! 4.5/5.

[ Reply ]